91亚色传媒

Open Letters

An open letter to the 91亚色传媒 executive director search committee

Peter Kennelly
Sept. 19, 2023

As the 91亚色传媒 seeks to hire a new executive director by the end of this year, I’m writing today to share my thoughts on the process.

I have been an 91亚色传媒 member since 1986. Since 2007, I have continually served the society in a variety of roles. I have chaired the Education and Professional Development Committee and, later, the 91亚色传媒 Committee. I served on the Journal of Biological Chemistry editorial board from 2010 to 2015. I worked on the accreditation program and with members of the Maximizing Access Committee (then the Minority Affairs Committee) on Hands-on Opportunities to Promote Engagement in Sciences, or HOPES, a National Science Foundation–funded K–12 science outreach program. I have had the pleasure of working closely with both Barbara Gordon and Steve Miller. As a faculty member and former department head, I have extensive experience with a wide range of leadership styles.

I care deeply about the 91亚色传媒. Having chaired or sat on many university search committees looking to fill administrative positions, I am all too familiar with the inevitable assertion, generally from an administrator, that executive experience is the indispensable qualification by which to judge applicants — that, first and foremost, we need someone who is a master of the spreadsheet. 

I beg to disagree. 

As you know, our society is at a crossroads. The steady revenue stream provided by subscriptions to our journals has evaporated with the decision to move to open access. In my opinion, there is no viable steady-state model for 91亚色传媒. We cannot go on as we are. Either we will become THE society of biochemistry and molecular biology writ large, or we will slowly fade away. 

The times demand an executive director who possesses a big-picture vision, an appreciation for the breadth and diversity of our society, an ability to connect with the many members whose volunteerism makes possible so much of what the 91亚色传媒 is and does, and the boldness to dare.

As you sift through the applications, especially each applicant's vision statement and external letters of recommendation, look for signs of altruism, vision and an investment mentality rather than the extent of administrative experience and managerial acumen. For example, does a candidate effortlessly credit others, writing or speaking in terms of teams, communities and groups, or do they constantly talk in terms of me, my and I? Do they think and act incrementally or in transformative terms? Do they acknowledge their shortcomings while exhibiting a steady internal compass? Don't be afraid to embrace someone with the "right stuff," even though they may seem relatively young and inexperienced. 

Speaking as a former department head and committee chair, I believe that administrative experience is overrated. Administrative skills can be learned, and lack of experience can be addressed through effective partnership with staff. Imagination, vision, empathy and conviction cannot acquired from a book or a workshop. 

We need to be willing to dare if the 91亚色传媒 is to grow and diversify. And that’s what it must do to match the global impact of our discipline and the needs of our members, both present and future.

Enjoy reading 91亚色传媒 Today?

Become a member to receive the print edition four times a year and the digital edition weekly.

Learn more
Peter Kennelly

Peter Kennelly is a professor of biochemistry at the Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University.

Get the latest from 91亚色传媒 Today

Enter your email address, and we鈥檒l send you a weekly email with recent articles, interviews and more.

Latest in Opinions

Opinions highlights or most popular articles

Our top 10 articles of 2024
Editor's Note

Our top 10 articles of 2024

Dec. 25, 2024

91亚色传媒 Today posted more than 400 original articles this year. The ones that were most read covered research, society news, policy, mental health, careers and more.

From curiosity to conversation: My first science café
Essay

From curiosity to conversation: My first science café

Dec. 18, 2024

鈥淲hy was I so nervous? I鈥檇 spoken in hundreds of seminars and classes, in front of large audiences.鈥 But this was the first time Ed Eisenstein was explaining his research 鈥渢o a crowd of nonscientists relaxing over food and drink at a local tavern.鈥

鈥極ne word or less鈥
Essay

鈥極ne word or less鈥

Dec. 18, 2024

For a long time, Howard Steinman thought this phrase was a joke: 鈥淟ess than one word is no words, and you can't answer a question without words.鈥

Can we make grad school more welcoming for all?
Essay

Can we make grad school more welcoming for all?

Dec. 11, 2024

The students and faculty at most of the institutions training the next generation of STEM professionals do not reflect the country鈥檚 diversifying demographics, leaving a gap in experience and cultural understanding.

I am not a fake. I am authentically me
Essay

I am not a fake. I am authentically me

Dec. 5, 2024

Camellia Moses Okpodu explains why she believes the term 鈥渋mposter syndrome鈥 is inaccurate and should be replaced.

Where do we search for the fundamental stuff of life?
Essay

Where do we search for the fundamental stuff of life?

Dec. 1, 2024

Recent books by Thomas Cech and Sara Imari Walker offer two perspectives on where to look for the basic properties that define living things.